New York FSBO Guide 2026
How to sell your home without an agent in New York — Property Condition Disclosure, attorney-required closing, MLS access for NYC and Buffalo.
New York requires an attorney at closing. A good real estate attorney costs $1,500–$3,000. On a $900K NYC-area sale, a 6% commission would be $54,000. The attorney is a small fraction of what you save going FSBO.
Selling FSBO in New York
New York is one of the highest-savings FSBO markets in the country. Attorney fees are required but modest relative to the commissions at stake — NYC borough median prices run $700K–$900K, Westchester County averages around $850K, and Long Island (Nassau County) averages $600K+. A 3% listing commission on an $800K NYC-area home is $24,000. A real estate attorney costs $1,500–$3,000. The math strongly favors FSBO even with the attorney requirement.
The Property Condition Disclosure Statement is required before signing a contract, or you can offer a $500 credit in lieu — but most real estate attorneys strongly recommend completing the disclosure rather than paying the credit, as the disclosure limits your liability. NYC MLS access is more complex than most markets: REBNY (Real Estate Board of New York) has historically been restrictive about flat-fee listings in the five boroughs. Long Island uses OneKey MLS, Westchester uses OneKey as well, and Buffalo uses Buffalo Niagara MLS — all more accessible through flat-fee services.
What Makes New York Different for FSBO Sellers
- Attorney required — hire your own. New York requires an attorney at closing, and unlike Georgia (where the lender selects one), you hire your own real estate attorney. Budget $1,500–$3,000. Start interviewing attorneys before you list — do not wait until you have an offer, as good NY real estate attorneys book out quickly in spring.
- NYC transfer taxes are layered and significant. NYC sellers pay a city transfer tax (1% under $500K; 1.425% above $500K) plus New York State transfer tax ($2/$500 = 0.4%). On an $800K NYC sale, combined transfer taxes cost the seller approximately $13,400. There is also a "mansion tax" of 1–3.9% on purchases over $1M — paid by the buyer, but it affects negotiation dynamics at that price point.
- NYC co-ops require board approval. If you own a co-op (very common in NYC), the buyer must be approved by the co-op board. This is a significant contingency — boards can reject buyers, which can kill a deal after months of negotiation. Factor this into your marketing timeline.
- REBNY MLS access is limited for FSBO. REBNY in Manhattan has historically restricted flat-fee listings. Verify with your flat fee MLS provider whether they have active REBNY access before purchasing. Long Island (OneKey) and Buffalo (Buffalo Niagara MLS) are more accessible.
- The $500 credit in lieu of disclosure is rarely the right choice. Most NY real estate attorneys recommend completing the Property Condition Disclosure Statement rather than paying the $500 credit — the disclosure reduces your liability for undisclosed defects that surface after closing.
New York Markets
New York FSBO — Common Questions
Is FSBO legal in New York?
Yes. FSBO is legal in New York, but an attorney is required at closing — NY is an attorney-state. Budget $1,500–$3,000 for a real estate attorney. You still save dramatically vs. paying a listing agent commission on top of that.
What is the NY Property Condition Disclosure Act?
New York Real Property Law §462 requires sellers to provide a Property Condition Disclosure Statement to buyers before signing a contract. Alternatively, sellers can pay the buyer a $500 credit in lieu of disclosure — but most real estate attorneys recommend completing the disclosure instead.
What MLS covers New York City?
NYC uses REBNY (Real Estate Board of New York) and is notoriously hard for FSBO sellers to access via flat-fee MLS. Long Island and Westchester use OneKey MLS, which is more accessible. Some flat-fee services have limited NYC MLS access — verify before signing up.
What MLS covers Buffalo?
Buffalo uses the Buffalo Niagara MLS, accessible through flat-fee MLS services. More straightforward than NYC for FSBO sellers.
When is the best time to sell FSBO in New York?
Spring (mid-March to mid-June) is peak season statewide. NYC has a stronger fall market than most cities (September–November). Winter (December–February) is slow but motivated buyers are active. Summer is quieter outside NYC.
Is New York a transfer tax state?
Yes — New York has multiple transfer taxes. NYC sellers pay city and state transfer taxes (~2.05% on sales over $500K). Statewide, the basic transfer tax is $2/$500 of value ($4/$1,000). These are seller costs and must be factored into your net proceeds.
Seller Resources
Tools we've vetted for FSBO sellers. Affiliate disclosure. We may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase.
Moving & Hauling
HireAHelper
Hire local moving labor by the hour — loading, unloading, or packing. You supply the truck or portable container; they do the heavy lifting.
Find Moving LaborWe may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase.
Moving Labor Brokers
Compare quotes from vetted local moving labor crews. Flat hourly rates, no surprises. Book the crew, you handle the truck.
Compare Labor QuotesWe may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase.
U-Pack
ReloCubes and moving trailers at a fraction of full-service moving costs. You pack, they drive — ideal for cross-country moves.
Get a U-Pack QuoteWe may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase.
1-800-GOT-JUNK?
Full-service junk removal — they load, haul, and dispose. Clear out before photos or between moves. Same-day and next-day appointments available.
Book Junk RemovalWe may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase.
Storage
SpareFoot
Compare self-storage unit prices and availability in your area. Monthly contracts, climate-controlled options, no long-term commitment required.
Find Nearby StorageWe may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase.